WebAIM - Web Accessibility In Mind

E-mail List Archives

Re: Video and auto play

for

From: Mark Magennis
Date: Feb 9, 2022 3:02AM

I think you have to consider the context too. For example, suppose you have a list of courses where activating a course goes to a page with the course player. As someone else has said, a user may need time to do a few things before choosing to start playing the course, such as read the introduction, look at the table of contents, turn on captions or audio description, adjust playback speed, etc. A screen reader user will need to be able to use their screen reader to do this without the content audio competing with the screen reader output. So autoplay would not be good. But then consider when the user has gone some way through the course and is resuming at a later date. They may do this frequently, taking the course one lesson at a time. In this case selecting the course means "start again where I left off". It can be seen as equivalent to pressing Play, so autoplay may be appropriate. As long as focus is placed on a Pause button then they can easily stop it playing if they want to do something else before resuming.

One thing you have to watch out for though is automatic screen reader announcements. If going to the course involves a new HTML page load then the screen reader will read title, number of headings and links etc. If it is a virtual page load then you may have scripted a live region for the screen reader to announce the course title. If you move focus to the Pause button, the screen reader may announce the button, something like "button Pause press space to activate" (JAWS no longer does this since 2021 which is a major PITA). If the audio starts immediately then these announcements may be competing with it. So if you're using autoplay you want to not cause these announcements or either leave a short gap for them to happen before playback starts.

Mark

-----Original Message-----
From: WebAIM-Forum < <EMAIL REMOVED> > On Behalf Of Claire Forbes
Sent: 08 February 2022 20:28
To: <EMAIL REMOVED>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] [WebAIM] Video and auto play

Hello everyone, I'm hoping for some insight from you experts...

A customer is requesting auto play for their web-based training and I wanted to ensure that I provide appropriate feedback, as I know it's somewhat considered "bad form" for autoplay

The question is: Do students have to hit the arrow with each slide to play the audio? If the course is set to "audio auto play" would that make the course non-compliant?
The reasoning is as follows:
For 508 compliance, if slide content auto plays, then the testing condition = "all media/narration content must play (end) completely within 3 seconds"

* The "3-second play" condition applies to ALL media content (narration, videos, alerts, sounds, music, etc).
* This condition applies to ALL slides in the content (course).
The design decision = "do ALL slides in the course have narration/media that plays/ends completely within 3 seconds"?

* If "yes", then the entire course can be set to auto play.
* If "no" (i.e., some or all slides require a longer duration), then the entire course is set to "not auto play" (in order for the course GUI behavior to be consistent for the user).
From a "why is this a rule" point of view, the standard exists because auto play (narration/media) can startle and confuse people with learning disabilities, including people sensitive to too many things happening on the screen at one time or to sudden/unexpected noise/volume. Additionally, the hearing/vision-impaired user must have time to activate CC, simultaneous reader software issues, ... etc.

Thank you!
Claire


Claire Forbes
Project Control Specialist

Victor 12, Inc.
174 West Comstock Avenue Suite 104
​Winter Park, FL. 32789

Tel: 407-612-6011 x119
Fax: 407-985-1980
Web: www.victor12.com

CVE SDVOSB | VOSB | GSA Multiple Award Schedule (MAS) GS‑02F‑087BA This message is for the designated recipient only and may contain privileged, proprietary, or otherwise private information. ​ ​If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete the original. Any other use of the email by you is prohibited.