E-mail List Archives
Thread: Aural cues
Number of posts in this thread: 2 (In chronological order)
From: Ian.Lloyd
Date: Tue, Sep 17 2002 6:47AM
Subject: Aural cues
No previous message | Next message →
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
********************************************************************
The contents of this email are intended exclusively for the
addressee. If you are not the addressee you must not read
use or disclose the email contents ; you should notify us
immediately [ by clicking "Reply" ] and delete this email.
Nationwide monitors e-mails to ensure its systems operate
effectively and to minimise the risk of viruses. Whilst it has
taken reasonable steps to scan this email, it does not
accept liability for any virus that may be contained in it.
********************************************************************
I am after any help/advice about use of audio in applications. For example,
are there any standard conventions for sounds to use for events such as:
* correct
* incorrect
* forward, back, up, down
and so on.
Or is it more a case of - nice sounds for nice things, as long as you
explain them first?
[For anyone who finds themself copied in to this note (you will be BCCd) it
means I've either met you or heard about you and think you may have
something to contribute - please reply to me directly if you have been sent
the note in this way]
Ian Lloyd, Electronic Channels
Nationwide Building Society
e-mail: = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED =
tel: 01793-655260
fax: 01793-656368
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGPsdk version 1.1.1 (C) 1997 Pretty Good Privacy, Inc.
iQEVAwUBPYcwiG4wJNdvwuyFAQGKcAf/Y5OfMQFmn+9RRzI4BTl/BYlaryJLrcep
W25JRdEUyLK6TRMEIXZo7iPN8oyxX1Xl76gKQ7amOUHPUkvjO0lJvqo6a7M/ae69
+Tb6R1sB8awY4vv4arGIDPehFF2IMX65HECiOey1hXV7MeDo4QdiQKZRJQ6ziOck
dup8eHXBPP4kmKqIo4c52F554ThcMfPsiH2+/a/qNP0EApYVPrTfuITGwmUUNxHG
dujYdLFJfWjFSU6dTKmWFHRva/LtIQTrOg4emAwf+BWdDu0t7Rw6t/EqSCWnB1k/
/feXi2cpG/eUv3Ztli0SaWar/gcpzx9m4SRtV56O43lEn19rBcmIlA==HFXA
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
----
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or view list archives,
visit http://www.webaim.org/discussion/
From: Wendy R. Mullin
Date: Tue, Sep 17 2002 8:39AM
Subject: Re: Aural cues
← Previous message | No next message
Hi Ian -
I originally trained to be a school library media specialist - a.k.a.
school librarian. Evaluating educational software was a part of several of
my classes. I don't have a copy of the evaluation questions we used
anymore, but I've listed some of the evaluation questions/criteria below
that could be useful for software designed for children or adults. I've
also added some questions based upon my experience assisting others with
assistive technology for computers.
Is getting the incorrect answer more fun than getting the correct answer?
If for children (and some adults as well), don't make getting the incorrect
answer more fun than getting the correct answer. Many educational software
games and learning tools include crashes, bangs, and other sounds that many
students think are more fun than the sounds made for correct answers.
Does getting the incorrect answer cause an "insulting" or "degrading"
response?
I have seen software meant for children that make the following type
statements in response to an incorrect answer: "Hey stupid! That's not
right." Or "Are you an idiot or what?" (These are my paraphrases. I
can't remember the actually responses, but they did include the words
"stupid" and "idiot".)
Can the software be used without the sound turned on?
* Many computers don't have speakers or sound cards.
* Will your future audience of users be in a room by themselves - where
hearing the sounds won't disturb others? (Yes, users can where headphones,
but, especially in many public schools and public computing labs,
headphones tend to "disappear".)
* If a user has a hearing impairment, will they be able to understand the
software? For accessibility, a software application should not rely on
sound alone. Even if someone can hear the sounds, even a slight hearing
impairment (such as happens to many of us as we age) can create a problem
hearing some pitches or tones.
* Some individuals (especially if your audience will be adults) don't like
dings and other audible sounds and will turn them off. Some just don't
like the sounds, but others find them annoying and distracting. * For some
individuals with ADD/ADHD or other learning disabilities, sound can be very
distracting.
* If your audience will be adults, don't make the responses too "cute" or
"condescending", such as "That's right. You're doing great today!"
Does the software application have documentation? Is it written clearly
and understandably?
A good instructional manual is always desirable, but it can also be helpful
to have a shortened, version of the instructions available, such as a
"Quick Reference" instructional sheet that gives the basics of the software
application. (How many of us read through an entire manual before we start
to use a new piece of software or hardware?)
Does the software have a "help" feature included in the software itself or
online? While software manuals are great and necessary, they often are not
easily accessible. Individual users may put on a shelf or drawer. The
software may be passed onto the next person in a position without the
accompanying manual. Teachers, librarians, or others running a public
computer lab usually will lock the manual away for safe keeping. Also, if
an organization buys a site license that allows for multiple, simultaneous
users, only one or two sets of printed instructional manuals may be purchases.
Is the User Interface clear, understandable, and usable? You may or may
not have time for usability testing, but just showing the interface (even a
mock-up on paper) to someone other than yourself (and any other developers
of the software) can often give you insight into possible problem areas.
I'd be interested in the responses of others on this topic.
Wendy R. Mullin
Web Developer, University of South Carolina
= EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = | http://isg.csd.sc.edu/~wmullin/
At 02:39 PM 9/17/02 +0100, = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = wrote:
>I am after any help/advice about use of audio in applications. For example,
>are there any standard conventions for sounds to use for events such as:
>
>* correct
>* incorrect
>* forward, back, up, down
>
>and so on.
>
>Or is it more a case of - nice sounds for nice things, as long as you
>explain them first?
>
>Ian Lloyd, Electronic Channels
>Nationwide Building Society
----
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or view list archives,
visit http://www.webaim.org/discussion/