E-mail List Archives
Thread:
Number of posts in this thread: 1 (In chronological order)
From: Mark Magennis
Date: Wed, Oct 09 2019 3:02AM
Subject:
No previous message | No next message
Glen pointed out that even if you include the repeated link text "get it now" in context in the ways allowed for WCAG SC 2.4.4 compliance, that context is not available in a links list. Similarly, it is not directly available when you TAB through the links. To understand what "it" means, the user has to backtrack through the sentence, paragraph, list item, or table cell to discover the context. This is a major pain.
There's another consideration too. Users of voice activation software such as Dragon Naturally Speaking want to activate the link by saying "click" followed by the unique link name. They may guess (or find out) that the link name is always in the form "Get it now {product name}" so they can speak that. They could also use a two-step process of just saying "click link" and Dragon will number all the links on the page, then "press 17" or whatever number they want. But I'm informed that Dragon users feel this is unacceptable, making them "jump through hoops" to use the functionality. They want to be able to activate everything directly.
Glen, I quite like your idea of inserting the comma to get around the clumsy construct. Some time ago, when I was working on pages with repeated links "launch", "edit", "delete", etc. I was finding that some of them were very clumsy. I can't remember the particular examples but it was something like "get details". I thought it would be clever to add extra words in there, such as "for" to make it "get details for {object}" but then the Dragon issue came up. The comma would seem to not create that issue, although I actually doubt that it will make that much difference to most screen reader users who seem perfectly able to understand what to me sounds like verbal garbage spoken at 300 words per minute.
Mark
Mark Magennis
Skillsoft | mobile: +353 87 60 60 162
Accessibility Specialist