WebAIM - Web Accessibility In Mind

E-mail List Archives

Thread: Scalable or Responsive and why

for

Number of posts in this thread: 12 (In chronological order)

From: Szaj, Julie
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 12:09PM
Subject: Scalable or Responsive and why
No previous message | Next message →

--_004_SN6PR02MB499203DF3B746540358DCE7BB40B0SN6PR02MB4992namp_
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Hello Everyone,

There is discussion happening at my university regarding whether it is okay=
to create online training content that is scalable instead of responsive. =
I believe they should be responsive because they are more accessible. Argum=
ents for scalable are they are faster to create, thus cheaper for the clien=
t, and are "less frustrating" for the content creators. I would love to hea=
r your honest thoughts.

Julie

[signature]


The materials in this message are private and may contain Protected Healthc=
are Information or other information of a sensitive nature. If you are not =
the intended recipient, be advised that any unauthorized use, disclosure, c=
opying or the taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this info=
rmation is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, p=
lease immediately notify the sender via telephone or return mail.

--_004_SN6PR02MB499203DF3B746540358DCE7BB40B0SN6PR02MB4992namp_
Content-Type: image/png; name="image001.png"
Content-Description: image001.png
Content-Disposition: inline; filename="image001.png"; size=16800;
creation-date="Thu, 08 Oct 2020 18:09:02 GMT";
modification-date="Thu, 08 Oct 2020 18:09:02 GMT"
Content-ID: <image001.png@01D69D74.365B7960>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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--_004_SN6PR02MB499203DF3B746540358DCE7BB40B0SN6PR02MB4992namp_--

From: Jonathan Avila
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 12:12PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Responsive is much better for users with low vision so they do not have to scroll horizontally to read a line of text. It would also likely be needed to meet WCAG 2.1 SC 1.4.10 which indicates text should fit into a width of 320CSS pixels without scrolling in the direction of the text.

Jonathan

From: Aditya
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 12:44PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Responsive rearranges content blocks. Example, a list of links that are horizontally laid out would go under a hamburger menu when page is zoomed and users would have to navigate again to re orient and access content.
I guess it's picking what's best for your users.


Sent from my iPhone

> On Oct 8, 2020, at 1:12 PM, Jonathan Avila < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:
>
> Responsive is much better for users with low vision so they do not have to scroll horizontally to read a line of text. It would also likely be needed to meet WCAG 2.1 SC 1.4.10 which indicates text should fit into a width of 320CSS pixels without scrolling in the direction of the text.
>
> Jonathan
>
>

From: Swift, Daniel P.
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 12:48PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Going responsive makes obvious sense to me. The trend now is consuming content wherever you are and mobile devices aren't going anywhere ... I believe that this is a bridge that you will need to cross eventually. Up until about a year or 2 ago, our LMS was not mobile friendly at all and students were far from happy.

Do you have analytics on how your content is accessed? If possible, you can use that to make your argument.

Good luck!

Daniel Swift, MBA
Senior Web Specialist
University Communications and Marketing
West Chester University
610.738.0589

From: Patrick H. Lauke
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 1:34PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

On 08/10/2020 19:09, Szaj, Julie wrote:
> Hello Everyone,
>
> There is discussion happening at my university regarding whether it is okay to create online training content that is scalable instead of responsive. I believe they should be responsive because they are more accessible. Arguments for scalable are they are faster to create, thus cheaper for the client, and are "less frustrating" for the content creators. I would love to hear your honest thoughts.

What exactly is a "scalable" site rather than a responsive one?

--
Patrick H. Lauke

https://www.splintered.co.uk/ | https://github.com/patrickhlauke
https://flickr.com/photos/redux/ | https://www.deviantart.com/redux
twitter: @patrick_h_lauke | skype: patrick_h_lauke

From: Aditya
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 2:34PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Scalable, as I understand it, does not rearrange content. The relative positions are maintained. Or you can say that the content goes out of bounds of screen and users have to scroll to get content.

Responsive reacts to the view port and rearranges itself.

There might be a technical definition somewhere but that what I have observed.

Sent from my iPhone

> On Oct 8, 2020, at 2:34 PM, Patrick H. Lauke < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:
>
>> On 08/10/2020 19:09, Szaj, Julie wrote:
>> Hello Everyone,
>> There is discussion happening at my university regarding whether it is okay to create online training content that is scalable instead of responsive. I believe they should be responsive because they are more accessible. Arguments for scalable are they are faster to create, thus cheaper for the client, and are "less frustrating" for the content creators. I would love to hear your honest thoughts.
>
> What exactly is a "scalable" site rather than a responsive one?
>
> --
> Patrick H. Lauke
>
> https://www.splintered.co.uk/ | https://github.com/patrickhlauke
> https://flickr.com/photos/redux/ | https://www.deviantart.com/redux
> twitter: @patrick_h_lauke | skype: patrick_h_lauke
> > > >

From: glen walker
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 2:46PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

That just sounds like responsive and non-responsive.

Scalable is usually used in terms of volume. If you have a web app that
can handle a handful of users but crashes when more people connect, it's
not scalable.

So I think Patrick's clarifying question was trying to understand how
"scalable" ties in with accessibility with the original question. An app
being scalable vs responsive is not really the correct comparison since
they're separate things.


On Thu, Oct 8, 2020 at 2:36 PM Aditya via WebAIM-Forum <
= EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:

> Scalable, as I understand it, does not rearrange content. The relative
> positions are maintained. Or you can say that the content goes out of
> bounds of screen and users have to scroll to get content.
>
> Responsive reacts to the view port and rearranges itself.
>
> There might be a technical definition somewhere but that what I have
> observed.
>
> Sent from my iPhone
>
> > On Oct 8, 2020, at 2:34 PM, Patrick H. Lauke < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = >
> wrote:
> >
> > What exactly is a "scalable" site rather than a responsive one?
> >
> > --
> > Patrick H. Lauke
> >
>

From: Aditya
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 4:20PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Glen,

The term "scalable" is in reference to the html (like Max-scale and initial-scale).

The scalability you are referring to infrastructure related.



Sent from my iPhone

> On Oct 8, 2020, at 3:46 PM, glen walker < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:
>
> That just sounds like responsive and non-responsive.
>
> Scalable is usually used in terms of volume. If you have a web app that
> can handle a handful of users but crashes when more people connect, it's
> not scalable.
>
> So I think Patrick's clarifying question was trying to understand how
> "scalable" ties in with accessibility with the original question. An app
> being scalable vs responsive is not really the correct comparison since
> they're separate things.
>
>
> On Thu, Oct 8, 2020 at 2:36 PM Aditya via WebAIM-Forum <
> = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:
>
>> Scalable, as I understand it, does not rearrange content. The relative
>> positions are maintained. Or you can say that the content goes out of
>> bounds of screen and users have to scroll to get content.
>>
>> Responsive reacts to the view port and rearranges itself.
>>
>> There might be a technical definition somewhere but that what I have
>> observed.
>>
>> Sent from my iPhone
>>
>>> On Oct 8, 2020, at 2:34 PM, Patrick H. Lauke < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = >
>> wrote:
>>>
>>> What exactly is a "scalable" site rather than a responsive one?
>>>
>>> --
>>> Patrick H. Lauke
>>>
>>
> > > >

From: glen walker
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 5:14PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Ah, so like pinch and zoom scalable.

On Thu, Oct 8, 2020 at 4:22 PM Aditya via WebAIM-Forum <
= EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:

> Glen,
>
> The term "scalable" is in reference to the html (like Max-scale and
> initial-scale).
>
> The scalability you are referring to infrastructure related.
>
>
>

From: Vaughn, Michael
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 7:31PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

Perhaps you’re talking about Adobe Captivate output (uses <canvas> elements). Like this (sorry, I think the play button is not keyboard-operable):

https://community-portal-prod-previewdata.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/files/2020/08/2139ef2e658ec52ef9a1/index.html

It scales to fit the viewport, so resize the window and you’ll see what the “scaling” is all about. Try to do a page zoom and be prepared to be frustrated.

From: WebAIM-Forum < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = >
Date: Thursday, October 8, 2020 at 4:36 PM
To: WebAIM Discussion List < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = >
Cc: Aditya < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = >
Subject: Re: [WebAIM] Scalable or Responsive and why
Scalable, as I understand it, does not rearrange content. The relative positions are maintained. Or you can say that the content goes out of bounds of screen and users have to scroll to get content.

Responsive reacts to the view port and rearranges itself.

There might be a technical definition somewhere but that what I have observed.

Sent from my iPhone

> On Oct 8, 2020, at 2:34 PM, Patrick H. Lauke < = EMAIL ADDRESS REMOVED = > wrote:
>
>> On 08/10/2020 19:09, Szaj, Julie wrote:
>> Hello Everyone,
>> There is discussion happening at my university regarding whether it is okay to create online training content that is scalable instead of responsive. I believe they should be responsive because they are more accessible. Arguments for scalable are they are faster to create, thus cheaper for the client, and are "less frustrating" for the content creators. I would love to hear your honest thoughts.
>
> What exactly is a "scalable" site rather than a responsive one?
>
> --
> Patrick H. Lauke
>
> https://nam05.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.splintered.co.uk%2F&amp;data=02%7C01%7Cmichael.vaughn%40yale.edu%7C6b0e0e25f8d54339a0ba08d86bc9d02b%7Cdd8cbebb21394df8b4114e3e87abeb5c%7C0%7C0%7C637377861813610718&amp;sdata=65Dtc6OIX6ca4zl3ClWt%2Bfc79vc3xzmn0CDzDQJ5vhU%3D&amp;reserved=0 | https://nam05.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fgithub.com%2Fpatrickhlauke&amp;data=02%7C01%7Cmichael.vaughn%40yale.edu%7C6b0e0e25f8d54339a0ba08d86bc9d02b%7Cdd8cbebb21394df8b4114e3e87abeb5c%7C0%7C0%7C637377861813610718&amp;sdata=90g9t25tNSvbwgUhq5zOUm%2BtYTfEdmY%2BMmPCq286e08%3D&amp;reserved=0
> https://nam05.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fflickr.com%2Fphotos%2Fredux%2F&amp;data=02%7C01%7Cmichael.vaughn%40yale.edu%7C6b0e0e25f8d54339a0ba08d86bc9d02b%7Cdd8cbebb21394df8b4114e3e87abeb5c%7C0%7C0%7C637377861813610718&amp;sdata=39gRzeiIsuOfAHAGWP5tE%2BSKfY3FlfZtQIx6w%2FynPi4%3D&amp;reserved=0 | https://nam05.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.deviantart.com%2Fredux&amp;data=02%7C01%7Cmichael.vaughn%40yale.edu%7C6b0e0e25f8d54339a0ba08d86bc9d02b%7Cdd8cbebb21394df8b4114e3e87abeb5c%7C0%7C0%7C637377861813610718&amp;sdata=SGGWx%2FxCSouhqphMyM4VOuoVH6pueJK8xPP7PYb%2BvM4%3D&amp;reserved=0
> twitter: @patrick_h_lauke | skype: patrick_h_lauke
> > > >

From: Steve Green
Date: Thu, Oct 08 2020 7:49PM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | Next message →

The e-learning modules output by Articulate also scale to fit the viewport. It doesn't use <canvas> elements, but almost everything you see is an SVG (including all the text, buttons, form controls etc.). The content actually gets smaller as you increase the zoom level, presumably because the whitespace around the content gets bigger, effectively reducing the viewport size.

Steve Green
Managing Director
Test Partners Ltd


From: Szaj, Julie
Date: Mon, Oct 12 2020 9:52AM
Subject: Re: Scalable or Responsive and why
← Previous message | No next message

Thank you everyone for your thoughts and comments.

One of our teams that makes the decisions requiring content to be scalable vs responsive is going to keep the responsive design requirement. We use Adobe Captivate and have decided to create some templates that content creators could use if they choose. Unfortunately we have no support for content creators who use the software, so we are hoping some simple, branded templates would help.

Julie